How to Write Employee Performance Reviews: A Checklist Approach for HR Managers

AI in HR_2048x1152

For the

How to Write Employee Performance Reviews: A Checklist Approach for HR Managers

industry, monitoring key compliance metrics is essential to maintain standards and reduce risks. Focus on these areas:

As an HR manager, conducting employee performance reviews is a pivotal responsibility. These reviews play a key role in fostering employee growth, enhancing productivity, and aligning individual efforts with organizational goals. But how can you ensure that the process is productive, engaging, and impactful?

The key lies in adopting a structured approach, such as using checklists to streamline the review process, ensuring that critical points are covered consistently. In this blog, we’ll explore how to write employee performance reviews, how to set SMART employee goals, and introduce our new performance review checklist feature, designed to simplify and enhance the review process. 

Whether you’re conducting annual or quarterly reviews, this guide will help you create meaningful conversations that drive results.

Why Employee Performance Reviews Matter

Employee performance reviews are more than just routine evaluations—they are a powerful tool for aligning employee efforts with the broader goals of the organization. When done well, they offer a clear path for professional development, foster a culture of continuous improvement, and increase employee engagement.

According to a Gallup study, employees who receive regular feedback are 3.6 times more likely to be engaged at work. Engaged employees are not only more productive but also more committed to their organization’s success. This highlights the importance of conducting meaningful reviews that go beyond mere formalities.

How to Write Employee Performance Reviews: A Step-by-Step Guide

Performance reviews are most effective when they are structured, balanced, and forward-looking. Here’s a step-by-step guide to writing a review that benefits both the employee and the organization:

a. Review the Job Description

Start by revisiting the employee’s job description. It helps clarify expectations and responsibilities, especially if the role has evolved. This ensures that the performance review is anchored in the employee’s actual duties and not in assumptions.

b. Gather Employee Performance Insights

Before the review, gather comprehensive performance insights, including peer reviews, employee self-assessments, and feedback from colleagues or supervisors. Collecting these inputs allows you to create a holistic view of the employee’s performance, providing greater context and fairness.

c. Assess Past Performance

Look at previous performance reviews and feedback to identify patterns and track progress. Recognizing even small improvements can motivate employees and foster continuous growth. Make sure you’re building on past conversations rather than starting from scratch each time.

d. Use Data and Metrics

Ground your feedback in data rather than relying on subjective impressions. If an employee meets or exceeds specific targets—whether it’s sales figures, project timelines, or other measurable KPIs—back up your review with numbers. This approach adds credibility and clarity to your assessment.

e. Address Unconscious Bias

One crucial update is the need to be aware of biases that can distort the review process. Biases like anchor bias (over-reliance on first impressions) and recency bias (focusing on recent events) can impact your judgment. Avoid these by keeping your review focused on objective data and feedback from multiple sources. Consider using tools or equity-focused templates to remove biased language and ensure fairness in your evaluations.

f. Provide Balanced Feedback

Effective reviews balance celebrating achievements with addressing areas for improvement. Acknowledge strengths—whether they be leadership, creativity, or technical skills—while also framing challenges as opportunities for growth. Avoid overwhelming the employee with negatives; instead, offer constructive, actionable feedback.

g. Set SMART Goals

Setting clear and actionable goals is one of the most critical aspects of a performance review. Use the SMART framework (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) to ensure that goals are both actionable and aligned with the company’s objectives. For example:

  • Specific: "Increase client retention rate by 10% through improved customer engagement strategies."
  • Measurable: "Track progress using quarterly sales reports."
  • Achievable: "Leverage new CRM tools introduced this year to improve client communication."
  • Relevant: "Focus on key clients whose renewals will significantly impact quarterly revenue."
  • Time-bound: "Achieve this by the end of the fiscal year."

This structured goal-setting approach gives employees a clear direction and purpose moving forward.

h. Incorporate Employee Feedback

The best performance reviews are not monologues but conversations. Invite your employee to share their perspective, the challenges they’ve faced, and their career aspirations. When employees feel heard, they are more likely to engage with the feedback and take ownership of their development.

Tips to Write a Performance Review for an Employee: Key Elements

Writing an employee performance review requires you to focus on clarity, structure, and support. Here’s how you can ensure that the review is constructive and engaging:

  • Be specific in your feedback: Vague praise like "You did a great job" offers little insight. Instead, use specific examples: “Your leadership in managing the Q3 project contributed to a 15% increase in team efficiency.”
  • Use a conversational tone: Frame feedback in a supportive, forward-looking manner. For example, "I’ve noticed that while your project management skills are strong, there’s an opportunity to enhance your communication with cross-functional teams."
  • Ensure actionable outcomes: Every piece of feedback, whether positive or constructive, should lead to actionable steps. For example, after discussing an area for improvement, suggest next steps: “To improve cross-functional communication, I recommend attending our next leadership workshop.”

Employee Goals for Performance Reviews

Goals should be at the heart of every performance review. When employees leave a review with clear, achievable goals, they’re more likely to stay motivated and focused. Here’s how to effectively set and track employee goals:

a. Align Goals with Organizational Objectives

When setting goals, make sure they tie directly to the broader objectives of your company. This not only ensures that the employee’s work supports key initiatives but also gives them a sense of purpose within the organization.

b. Break Down Long-Term Goals

For larger, long-term goals, break them into smaller, manageable milestones. For example, if the goal is to "increase market share by 5% over the next year," create quarterly milestones that track progress and adjust strategies accordingly. Breaking down goals into smaller steps helps employees stay on track and not feel overwhelmed.

c. Track Goals Using Checklists

Using a digital checklist to assign and track employee goals during performance reviews helps ensure transparency and accountability. These checklists can be updated throughout the year, keeping both managers and employees aligned on progress.

Bottom Line? Building a Better Performance Review Process

Writing an employee performance review doesn’t have to be a daunting task. By following a structured, checklist-driven approach, HR managers can make the review process more consistent, objective, and impactful. Begin by clearly defining the goals of the review, providing specific feedback, and setting actionable, SMART goals for your employees.

FAQs for employee performance reviews

To reduce bias in performance reviews, focus on objective data and multiple sources of feedback. Use a structured approach like peer reviews, self-assessments, and role-specific metrics to create a balanced evaluation. Being aware of common biases such as recency bias (focusing on recent events) and proximity bias (favoring in-office employees over remote workers) is critical. Leveraging equity-focused templates can help remove biased language from reviews, ensuring fairness across all employees.

It’s important to create a conversation rather than a one-sided review. If an employee disagrees with the feedback, listen to their perspective and invite them to share their own experiences or challenges. Be open to discussing the feedback in detail and reviewing any additional data or examples that support your assessment. Having clear, measurable data and encouraging open dialogue will help both sides reach a mutual understanding.

Use the SMART framework—goals that are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. For instance, instead of vague goals like "improve performance," provide clear objectives: "Increase customer satisfaction scores by 5% in the next quarter by implementing new feedback strategies." This ensures that goals are actionable, trackable, and aligned with both employee development and company objectives.

Some of the best tools for managing performance reviews include HR management platforms like BambooHR, Workday, or Lattice, which streamline the review process with features like goal tracking, peer feedback, and performance metrics. Textio is a great tool for ensuring equitable feedback by flagging biased language, while Whale offers checklist functionality for tracking employee goals and progress throughout the year. These tools make the process more efficient, transparent, and aligned with best practices.

How does this free template stack up to Whale?

Customizable

Free

Free mobile app

Employee Training tools

Employee Onboarding tools

Automated Workflows

Reporting

Insights on knowledge

Insights on Checklist runs

A static checklist template

Create checklists with ease

Add and describe

Add your steps one at a time and offer a description for clarity sake

Add an input field

Offer the option to add comments or other inputs for each step

Assign to your team and track

Assign

Assign checklists to an individual or a team and in the office or on the go.

Track completion

Monitor when and who completed which tasks in the insights report.

Helping thousands of SMEs systemize and scale

Other features

The Whale Mobile App

Stay connected to your Whale content from anywhere with our mobile app—perfect for quick access to documentation and training while on the move.

Contextual Suggestions

Provide relevant, in-the-moment suggestions directly in your team’s browser, keeping knowledge accessible without disrupting workflows.

Auto-Translate

Instantly translate content in Whale cards, enabling seamless collaboration across multilingual teams.

Onboard, train and elevate your team
with Whale

Whale is AI-powered software for documenting processes and training.